[1] : The Collaborative International Dictionary of English v.0.48

tally \tal"ly\, v. t. imp.  p. p. tallied; p. pr.  vb. n.
   tallying. cf. f. tialler to cut. see tally, n.
   1. to score with correspondent notches; hence, to make to
      correspond; to cause to fit or suit.
      1913 webster

            they are not so well tallied to the present
            juncture.                             --pope.
      1913 webster

   2. naut. to check off, as parcels of freight going inboard
      or outboard. --w. c. russell.
      1913 webster

   tally on naut., to dovetail together.
      1913 webster
see also:
tallied tallying tally tally on 

[2] : The Collaborative International Dictionary of English v.0.48

tally \tal"ly\, v. i.
   1. to be fitted; to suit; to correspond; to match.
      1913 webster

            i found pieces of tiles that exactly tallied with
            the channel.                          --addison.
      1913 webster

            your idea . . . tallies exactly with mine.
                                                  --walpole.
      1913 webster

   2. to make a tally; to score; as, to tally in a game.
      1913 webster

   tally on naut., to man a rope for hauling, the men
      standing in a line or tail.
      1913 webster
see also:
tally on 

Tally >> T Words
Tally, definition of term: Tally
tally_pag1.html